Was I Close?

By Scot Hill

There are hundreds of stories of mines lost and found and lost again in the American West. Some, like the Lost Dutchman, are famous. Others, well…. they are in a way more personal.  Many famous authors have written about them, with J Frank Dobie being perhaps the best collector of tales that I know.  If you have an interest in such things his books “Apache Gold and Yaqui Silver” and “Tongues of the Monte” are highly recommended.  Another author who liked to work tales of lost Spanish silver into his stories was Louis L’Amour, including more than a few books that took place in an area that I found myself working one summer.  Whether or not Louis believed or just felt they were a good bit of flavor I don’t know but certainly some do. 

Most Forest Service Districts have a beginning of the season in-service for seasonal employees where you get the certs you need out of the way, get to know the other crews, and in general take care of the housekeeping before the real work begins.  Some districts include a talk by the local Level 4 (armed FS law enforcement officer) that can include signs of marijuana grows, issues with troublesome outfitters, roads and trails that are popular with drug traffickers and the like.  I first heard about  a family who spent each summer in a specific valley in the San Juans searching for a lost silver mine during one of those briefs. The San Juans of Colorado lie at the north end of the Rio Grande river valley. They’re not all that far north of Santa Fe, the colonial capital of the northernmost province of Spain in the new world. It wasn’t farfetched at all to think there might be an old Spanish mine up there.

This family was convinced that they had the correct valley, and it was just a matter of finding the mine in THEIR valley. They came in as early as possible in the summer and stayed late into the fall, and were very secretive and protective of THEIR valley.  This was almost 20 years ago so I don’t know if they are still in there or not, but at the time it was a real danger we were briefed on.   To this day I wonder if they ever found what they were looking for, and if I just missed what they were looking for.

For me it happened at the tail end of a long day when the light was already starting to fall. We had spent the day working the “misery whip” saw up a trail and were ready to get into camp and end our day.  As the song says, “Day is done”, and the sun was already edging over the surrounding peaks.  As we rode through the evening dusk I saw a carving in an aspen out of the corner of my eye. That country is covered with carvings made by shepherds and I always liked to look at these works of art made by lonely men. This carving was different though.

It was an ornate Spanish style cross carved into a big old aspen, and one arm of it was longer than the other. Lore has it that such crosses were used as directional indicators to important places.  I noted the cross, but figured I would give it a closer look when I went through the area later.  And so the tale always goes – a man with work to get done, or tired from work already done, makes note of a “sure sign” of buried treasure thinking that he’ll be back when he has more time.

Well, I came back again too when I had more time. And just as the story usually goes, I could never find that cross again. Funny thing, I’d been up that same trail before without seeing the cross, but the significance of that didn’t really strike me the one time I did see it. So I’m left with the same thing most treasure seekers get – nothing but a memory. In the fading light of day one afternoon in the high country, did I see an arrow to a lost Spanish hoard? Was I close, or...

J. Frank Dobie


For many indigenous cultures, you cannot make a map of a place without including the stories that go with it. From the dreamtime of australian aborigines to the wintercount of plains indians, stories matter and stories about places matter even more. Our stories about the land connect us to the land, but they also become a part of the land itself in a very real way. Here then is a collection of stories about our land. 

Marked This Happened to Me! The Year The Snow Came Was I Close?

We are always accepting submissions at info@hillpeoplegear.com. Fiction or non-fiction. The only criteria is that it must be evocative of the land you stand on. If we like it, we'll publish it. The author will get attribution in the manner of their choosing.